Skip to content
The scholarly publishing briefReader updates ↓
Scholarly Publishing DailyKeeping Pace With the Changing Scholarly Publishing Landscape Back to articles
Search
Updates ↗
Menu
Journals

Corrections, Expressions of Concern and Retractions: Building Reliable Post-Publication Journal Workflows

Build reliable post-publication journal workflows for corrections, expressions of concern and retractions, with clear decisions, version history and update metadata.

Hands reviewing printed charts and documents beside a laptop.
Close-up of female and male hands pointing at business document while discussing it
In this article

Journal corrections: editorial responsibility after publication

Journal corrections help readers understand what has changed after publication, while journal retractions explain when findings should no longer be relied on. A research article is accepted, typeset, indexed and read by scholars worldwide. Months later, a reader questions a figure. The authors explain that the wrong image file was submitted, while a separate concern suggests the underlying findings might be unreliable. The journal must investigate, communicate fairly and decide what readers should be told. The manuscript submission system may have handled peer review perfectly, but it is the post-publication workflow that now protects the scholarly record.

This responsibility is receiving renewed attention. The Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) updated its retraction guidelines in 2025, emphasizing that retraction corrects the literature rather than punishing authors. The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) also provides guidance on corrections, versioning, expressions of concern and retractions. For journal managers, journal corrections and retractions need repeatable processes supported by editorial tools and hosting platforms.

Three notices, three different purposes

A correction is appropriate when an error requires a transparent update but the work remains sufficiently reliable. Examples might include a mislabeled table, an author affiliation error or an analytical issue whose impact can be explained and corrected. The journal should assess the significance of the problem rather than assuming that every error is trivial.

An expression of concern alerts readers that serious questions remain unresolved. It can be appropriate when evidence is incomplete, an external investigation is delayed or the journal cannot yet determine whether the results can be relied upon. It should not be presented as a finding of misconduct. The notice must explain the concern and, when suitable, what is still being examined.

A retraction signals that an article’s findings or other essential content are unreliable enough that readers should not rely on it. Serious errors can be honest; misconduct is not a necessary precondition. COPE’s 2025 guidance states that editorial independence matters: publishers can assist and advise, but the editor ordinarily makes the final retraction decision unless a conflict or similar complication requires another process.

These categories should be defined in a journal’s public policy for journal corrections and retractions. A workflow should help apply editorial judgment consistently, not automate a high-stakes decision based on an allegation keyword or a plagiarism score.

Treat each concern as a documented case

Every concern that may lead to journal corrections should receive a case identifier connected to the affected article. Record when and how it was raised, the evidence supplied, which journal staff may view it, and the editor responsible for assessment. Preserve relevant correspondence and the original published files. Access must be restricted because allegations may include confidential or sensitive information.

A helpful workflow begins with triage. Is the issue factual, methodological, ethical, legal or a complaint about disagreement in interpretation? Does it affect conclusions or only presentation? Is more than one article implicated? Can the journal assess the matter independently, or should an institution or other authority investigate? Assign a responsible editor and deadlines for the next review, while allowing exceptions for complex cases.

The case record should distinguish verified facts from claims under investigation. Staff should not silently change an article or communicate that a person is guilty merely because a concern was reported. Good systems support documented decisions, multiple reviewers where necessary and an appeal or reconsideration process consistent with editorial policy.

Communication can determine whether a process is trusted

Authors should generally have a fair opportunity to respond to substantive concerns. Editors may need to contact institutions, research integrity officers or other journals, depending on the issue. Communication templates can improve consistency, but correspondence should be tailored to the evidence and the recipient. A rigid automated email sequence is unsuitable when reputations and scientific reliability are at stake.

Create internal status labels such as ‘assessment’, ‘author response requested’, ‘external investigation’, ‘decision pending’ and ‘notice approved’. These are operational labels, not public verdicts. Separate case-status visibility from the public article-status indicator: readers may need an expression of concern before a case is resolved, but should not see confidential correspondence or speculative internal notes.

Timeliness also matters. COPE explains that when a serious problem is established, a retraction notice should not be unnecessarily delayed; where a final determination is delayed, an expression of concern may be appropriate. Tracking overdue cases and scheduling editorial review meetings helps journals act promptly without imposing arbitrary automatic outcomes.

The technical work begins after the editorial decision

When journal corrections are approved, the technical workflow begins. The journal should publish a clearly labeled, citable notice explaining what changed and linking to the affected article. ICMJE guidance recommends a new article version with change details and dates, preservation of prior versions, and a visible indication on older versions that a newer version exists. This approach gives readers an accountable history rather than overwriting the record without explanation.

For a retraction, the article ordinarily remains accessible and is prominently marked as retracted. ICMJE recommends labeling the status throughout relevant formats, including abstracts, full text and PDFs, and linking the original and notice in both directions. Removing the article entirely would make it harder to understand what had been cited or why its status changed. Exceptional removal decisions require their own policy and justification.

Production teams must also update tables of contents, journal search results, feeds, landing pages, downloads and any hosted versions. A banner on the article HTML is insufficient if an earlier PDF remains in circulation with no status indication.

Metadata is how notices travel beyond the journal site

An article may appear in discovery services, reference managers, library catalogs, repositories and research assessment systems. Publicizing an update therefore requires more than publishing a notice locally. Crossref provides guidance for linking versions and registering corrections, retractions and related updates. Its Crossmark service can show readers a work’s current status in online and PDF environments when publishers provide accurate update metadata.

Crossref also makes Retraction Watch information available through its data services. This can help third-party systems identify changes, but journals should still deposit their own accurate notices and relationships. A metadata record should include the original work identifier, notice identifier, update type, date and relevant relationship. Teams should verify how external systems display the change rather than assuming an API deposit is instantly reflected everywhere.

A useful quality-control check asks: can a reader reach the notice from the original article, reach the article from the notice, and see the status in the PDF and metadata feed? If any answer is no, dissemination is incomplete.

A journal corrections workflow that platforms can support

A reliable journal corrections system can represent the process as a connected sequence: intake, classification, evidence review, editorial decision, notice drafting, author communication, publication, metadata deposit and follow-up. Each transition should have a permitted role, a required record and a timestamp. Notifications can remind staff about unresolved cases without exposing confidential allegations.

For multi-journal organizations, the platform should offer shared capabilities while allowing journal-specific editors and policies. A central production team may handle notice templates and metadata deposition, but editorial accountability must remain clear. Dashboards can aggregate operational metrics without showing details from restricted cases to users who do not need them.

The workflow should also handle multiple connected articles. COPE’s updated guidelines discuss batch retractions, recognizing that one investigation can affect a collection of publications. Systems therefore need relationships among cases and notices, not just a single ‘retracted’ checkbox in an article table.

Test the process before a crisis

Test journal corrections and retractions using hypothetical cases: a minor numerical correction, an unresolved image concern, an institution-confirmed unreliable dataset and a complex group of related papers. Check who can open a case, who can approve a notice, whether editors can track deadlines, and whether each publication format receives the correct update.

Operational measures can include time to acknowledge a concern, time between editorial decision and public notice, completeness of metadata deposits, proportion of notices linked bidirectionally and unresolved cases requiring attention. Avoid rewarding rapid case closure alone; complex, fair investigations may take time. Measure accuracy and communication quality alongside timeliness. For the reader-facing side of this work, see how to make correction notices easier to understand.

The takeaway

Managing journal corrections is an ongoing commitment to accuracy, fairness and transparency. Clear distinctions among corrections, expressions of concern and retractions help editors choose the right response. Case tracking preserves evidence and responsibility; version control preserves history; persistent identifiers and update metadata inform the wider research ecosystem. A mature journal platform does not decide what science is valid. It makes carefully reached editorial decisions visible, durable and consistent wherever the article is read.

Sources and further reading

The daily briefing

Follow the developments shaping scholarly communication.

A clear daily briefing on open research, integrity, libraries and platforms.

Complete your subscription on the next page.